2924

2924

A California Homeowner Sued Only the Foreclosure Trustee, Left His Lender Out, and Got the Sale Stopped

Two claims the recorded documents contradict stopped a foreclosure sale on a matured $2 million loan.

Nov 18, 2026
∙ Paid

Every week: one real lawsuit filed over a California foreclosure, taken apart.

The File

Case: Moyer v. First American Title Insurance Company
Court: Superior Court of California, County of Santa Clara
Filed: 9/21/2026. Represented by counsel.
Property: Single-family home, San Martin.
Loan: Second deed of trust. $2,000,000, recorded June 2021, matured 12/10/2025.
Claims: 3. Notice of default mailing, reinstatement quote, unfair business practices.
Relief sought: An order stopping the trustee’s sale and any collection on the loan, plus damages, emotional distress damages and attorney’s fees.
Exhibits attached: None.


The Timeline

11/10/1999. The homeowner and his wife buy the property, per the recorded grant deed.

12/10/2020. A California corporation signs a $2,000,000 promissory note to a bank, per the deed of trust that later secures it.

6/15/2021. A $1,935,500 first deed of trust from a different lender is recorded on the property, per county property records.

6/22/2021. The bank’s deed of trust is recorded. The homeowner signed it as trustor, pledging the property for the corporation’s note. The deed of trust names the corporation as the borrower.

12/10/2025. The loan matures. The unpaid principal of $2,062,116.76 becomes due and payable, per the recorded Notice of Default.

6/26/2026. The foreclosure trustee records the Notice of Default on a Friday. The bank’s attached declaration checks two boxes: that it contacted the borrower, and that it used due diligence to try to contact him.

7/6/2026. The trustee mails the notice to the property, and it is returned to sender, per the complaint.

9/2026. The homeowner says a copy of the notice reached him in early September.

9/21/2026. The homeowner files this lawsuit against the foreclosure trustee only. The bank is not named.

10/7/2026. The trustee records the Notice of Trustee’s Sale. Sale set for 11/6/2026.

10/28/2026. The court grants a temporary restraining order stopping the sale, with no bond required.

10/29/2026. The trustee’s sale status page shows the sale canceled.

12/1/2026. The court’s hearing on whether to keep the sale stopped while the case goes on (a preliminary injunction).


The Money

$1,067,000. The 1999 purchase price, per county property records.

$2,000,000. The original amount of the note, per the recorded deed of trust.

$1,935,500. The amount of the first deed of trust, recorded a week before the bank’s, per county property records.

$2,062,116.76. The unpaid principal that came due on December 10, 2025, with interest at 6.93 percent, per the recorded Notice of Default.

$2,571,144.86. The amount due as of June 26, 2026, per the same notice.

$2,616,783.71. The unpaid balance plus estimated costs when the sale notice published, per the recorded Notice of Trustee’s Sale.


Claim 1. Notice of Default Mailing (§ 2924b)

The complaint says the Notice of Default recorded on June 26, 2025. It recorded on June 26, 2026, and the complaint’s own mailing date is ten days later.

What the statute requires

  • Within 10 business days after the Notice of Default is recorded, the party that recorded it must deposit a copy in the mail by registered or certified mail.

  • The copy shows the recording date. It goes to anyone who recorded a request for it, and to the trustor’s last known address if that differs from the address in the deed of trust.

What the homeowner alleges

The homeowner says the trustee tried to mail the notice to the property on July 6, 2026, and the letter came back for reasons he does not know. He says he did not learn of the foreclosure until early September, which cost him the notice period the law gives before a sale.

What the record shows

The Notice of Default carries a recording stamp of June 26, 2026, at 11:06 a.m. The deed of trust asks that notices of default go to the trustor at the property address it lists for him. No mailing records are attached to the complaint.


Claim 2. Reinstatement Quote (§ 2924c)

The homeowner says he asked for a reinstatement figure and got a payoff figure. The Notice of Default states the unpaid principal became all due and payable on December 10, 2025.

What the statute requires

  • A borrower can reinstate by paying only the amounts in default, plus permitted costs, and the loan continues as if it had not been accelerated.

  • That right applies when the principal came due before the maturity date fixed in the loan, because of a missed payment or another default.

What the homeowner alleges

The homeowner says he asked the trustee for a reinstatement quote and received a quote for the total payoff instead. He says he wants to reinstate and cannot do so without the quote.

What the record shows

The Notice of Default lists one default: the unpaid principal of $2,062,116.76, plus interest at 6.93 percent, which “became all due and payable on 12/10/2025.” It states $2,571,144.86 due as of June 26, 2026. The request and the payoff quote are not attached to the complaint.


Claim 3. Unfair Business Practices (Bus. & Prof. Code § 17200)

This claim is built on the first two. It adds no new facts and asks only for an order stopping the practices it describes.

What the statute requires

  • The unfair competition law covers business practices that are unlawful, unfair or fraudulent.

What the homeowner alleges

The homeowner says the trustee’s conduct and its violation of the foreclosure statutes are unfair business practices, and he asks for an injunction.

What the record shows

The trustee’s sale status page shows the November 6, 2026 sale canceled on October 29, 2026. No sale has been held.

🔒 Paid below: the takeaway and three lessons for lenders.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of 2924.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Balance Origins, LLC · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.