Every week: one real lawsuit filed over a California foreclosure, taken apart.
The File
Case: Akrabian v. California Mortgage Association
Court: U.S. District Court, Eastern District of California
Filed: 9/24/2026, almost seven years after the trustee’s sale. Represented by counsel.
Property: Single-family residence on a 6,226-square-foot lot, Lancaster, CA.
Loan: Second deed of trust. $212,000, recorded April 2006, matured April 1, 2021.
Claims: 11. Seven federal civil rights claims, three requests for declarations about § 2924.13, and a petition to set aside the 2019 trustee’s sale.
Relief sought: An order setting aside the 2019 sale and canceling the trustee’s deed, or, if a good-faith buyer now holds the property, $375,075.92 in “lost equity.” Damages including that lost equity. Declarations that earlier judgments do not bind the borrowers and that § 2924.13 applies to their sale. Attorney’s fees.
Exhibits attached: Two declarations, with 16 exhibits to the borrower’s declaration, including the note, the deed of trust, the recorded assignments and the 2018 Notice of Default.
The Timeline
5/23/2002. The borrower and her husband take title by grant deed. Purchase price $188,000, per county property records.
2/26/2004. A $128,600 deed of trust records against the property, per county property records.
4/6/2006. The $212,000 second deed of trust records. The borrower alone signs the note. Her husband signs the deed of trust with her but not the note.
1/1/2008. The borrower stops paying. The installment due on this date and the installments after it go unpaid, per the recorded Notice of Default.
2/4/2008. The original lender sends the borrower a letter titled “Notice of Default and Acceleration” by certified mail, asking for $2,650.28 by 3/5/2008.
10/26/2009. The securitization trust that held the loan reports a realized loss of $201,887.50 on it, per an investor report attached to the complaint.
4/20/2011. The borrower and her husband receive a Chapter 7 bankruptcy discharge, per the complaint.
2/13/2013. An assignment of the deed of trust to the securitization trust records.
11/20/2013. An assignment to a new servicer records.
8/17/2017. A corrective assignment to that servicer records.
8/21/2017. An assignment to an affiliate of the successor lender records, per county property records.
2/8/2018. An assignment from that affiliate to the successor lender records.
5/8/2018. The foreclosure trustee records a Notice of Default showing $167,610.30 to reinstate.
9/14/2018. The borrower files a Chapter 13 bankruptcy, per the complaint.
10/16/2018. The successor lender files a proof of claim in that bankruptcy for $352,999.09.
9/23/2019. The Notice of Trustee’s Sale records, showing $368,950.27.
10/16/2019. The trustee’s sale runs. The successor lender buys the property with a credit bid.
10/22/2019. The Trustee’s Deed Upon Sale records. The unpaid debt and the bid are both $375,075.92.
3/12/2021. The eviction court enters judgment for the successor lender and finds the sale “properly and validly conducted.” The couple left the bench trial before the successor lender finished its case, per the minute order.
4/9/2021. The borrower’s quiet title lawsuit is dismissed, per the complaint.
8/25/2021. The couple is evicted, per the complaint.
11/30/2021. The successor lender’s grant deed to three new buyers records. Price $500,000, per county property records.
12/3/2024. A federal court in Los Angeles dismisses the borrower’s earlier lawsuit with prejudice, per the complaint.
6/30/2025. Section 2924.13 takes effect.
9/24/2026. The borrower and her husband file this lawsuit.
The Money
$188,000. The 2002 purchase price, per county property records.
$128,600. The 2004 deed of trust, recorded before the second loan, per county property records.
$212,000. The second loan, per the note. Fixed rate of 5.875%, payments of $1,254.06 a month, balance due April 1, 2021.
$2,650.28. The amount to cure the default by March 5, 2008, per the original lender’s letter.
$201,887.50. The realized loss the securitization trust reported in October 2009, per an investor report.
$333,415.01. The amount the couple says the successor lender demanded in letters starting about August 2017.
$167,610.30. The amount to reinstate as of May 7, 2018, per the recorded Notice of Default.
$352,999.09. The total debt claimed in the 2018 bankruptcy, per the successor lender’s proof of claim.
$368,950.27. The unpaid balance and charges, per the recorded Notice of Trustee’s Sale.
$375,075.92. The unpaid debt and the successor lender’s credit bid, per the recorded Trustee’s Deed Upon Sale.
$38,533.52. Holdover damages awarded against the couple, per the eviction judgment.
$500,000. The 2021 resale price, per county property records. The buyers financed $400,000 with a new lender.
$375,075.92. The equity the couple says they lost, per the complaint.
The Claims
The borrower and her husband plead eleven claims. Only one asks for the property back.
Claims 1 through 7 are federal civil rights claims against the successor lender and the foreclosure trustee. Six ask the court to hold that the couple’s earlier losses cannot bar this case. The seventh says California’s foreclosure and eviction process took their property without due process or a jury, and asks for damages.
Claims 8 through 10 ask for declarations that § 2924.13 is constitutional and applies to sales held before it took effect. Two trade associations, one for private lenders and one for foreclosure trustees, are sued only on these.
Claim 11 asks the court to set aside the 2019 sale and cancel the trustee’s deed under § 2924.13 and § 3412.
The four sections below set the loan facts these claims depend on against the record.
1. The 2008 Acceleration
The couple says the original lender accelerated the loan on March 5, 2008. The letter they attach says the loan “will be accelerated” only if the default is not cured.
What the borrower and her husband allege
They say the default was never cured, so the whole balance came due on March 5, 2008, and nobody ever reversed that. On their count, a four-year period to sue on the note ran out in 2012 and a six-year period ran out in 2014. The borrower says she does not recall receiving the 2008 letter.
What the record shows
The February 4, 2008 letter asks for $2,650.28 by March 5 and says failure to cure “will result in the acceleration of your debt.” The deed of trust says that after the cure date the lender, “at Lender’s option may declare” the sums due. The complaint attaches no document from 2008 through 2017 declaring that the loan was accelerated.
The first one in the record is the 2018 Notice of Default, which says the beneficiary “has declared and does hereby declare all sums secured thereby immediately due and payable.” The complaint calls the loan a home equity line of credit. The note is a fixed-rate balloon note due April 1, 2021.
2. Nine Years Without a Letter (§ 2924.13)
The couple says no servicer wrote to them about the second loan from 2008 until about 2017. The statute that makes that silence unlawful took effect on June 30, 2025, almost six years after the sale.
What the statute requires
A servicer of a junior lien commits an unlawful practice if it gives the borrower no written communication about the loan for at least three years.
Conducting or threatening a sale after the statute of limitations expired is also an unlawful practice.
Before foreclosing, the servicer, beneficiary or trustee records a certification under penalty of perjury, at the same time as the Notice of Default, stating that no unlawful practice occurred or listing each one.
What the borrower and her husband allege
The loan passed through several holders and servicers, and the couple says none of them sent a letter, statement or notice. They describe collection calls in 2013 through 2015, and say letters demanding $333,415.01 began about August 2017. They acknowledge that two federal trial courts in the same district declined to apply § 2924.13 to conduct before it took effect. Their answer is that the Legislature meant it to reach back to the mortgage crisis.
What the record shows
The complaint attaches no written communication about the second loan dated between February 2008 and 2017. The first writings in the record are the successor lender’s 2018 payoff and reinstatement statements. The Notice of Default recorded in May 2018, seven years before § 2924.13 took effect, and no certification under that section is attached to it.
3. Getting the Property Back (§ 2924.13, § 3412)
The couple asks the court to cancel the 2019 trustee’s deed and return the property. The successor lender sold it in 2021 for $500,000 to buyers the complaint does not name.
What the statute requires
A borrower may petition the court to set a sale aside when the certification under § 2924.13 was never recorded, or when the recorded certification indicates an unlawful practice or a misrepresented compliance history.
The next subdivision says a failure to comply with § 2924.13 “shall not affect the validity of a trustee’s sale or a sale in favor of a bona fide purchaser.”
Under § 3412, a court may cancel a written instrument that is void or voidable against the person asking, when leaving it outstanding may cause that person serious injury.
What the borrower and her husband allege
Their theory is that the successor lender bought at its own sale and is not a good-faith purchaser, so the trustee’s deed should be canceled. They also sue ten unnamed defendants who “claim any right, title, or interest” through the sale. If the property has passed to a good-faith buyer, they ask instead for $375,075.92 in lost equity.
What the record shows
The Trustee’s Deed Upon Sale names the successor lender as the buyer and states “The Grantee Herein was The Foreclosing Beneficiary.” County property records show a grant deed recorded November 30, 2021 conveying the property to three individual buyers for $500,000, with a $400,000 loan from a new lender. A property report dated October 26, 2026 lists those buyers as the owners and does not list a recorded notice of this lawsuit.
4. The Lost Equity
The couple values their lost equity at $375,075.92. That is the unpaid debt, to the cent, stated on the recorded trustee’s deed.
What the borrower and her husband allege
The borrower says she “calculates” the lost equity at $375,075.92. The complaint calls the debt “time-barred, liquidated, and discharged,” so on the couple’s theory the lender was owed nothing. The borrower also says her bankruptcy lawyer told her the personal obligation was gone, “although a lien might still sit on the property.”
What the record shows
The Trustee’s Deed Upon Sale states: “The Amount of The Unpaid Debt was $375,075.92. The Amount Paid By The Grantee was $375,075.92.” The complaint gives no appraisal or valuation of the property.
🔒 Paid below: the takeaway and three lessons for lenders.


