Every week: one real lawsuit filed over a California foreclosure, taken apart.
The File
Case: Litinetsky v. Newrez
Court: Superior Court of California, County of Placer
Filed: 9/28/2026, the day before the scheduled trustee’s sale. In pro per: the borrower represents herself.
Property: Two condominium units in a resort building, Olympic Valley.
Loan: First deed of trust. $1,000,000, recorded February 2006, matures March 2036. Modified by a loan modification recorded September 2023.
Claims: 5. Dual tracking and the modification appeal, single point of contact, acknowledgment of application documents, accuracy of foreclosure documents, declaratory and injunctive relief.
Relief sought: An order stopping the 9/29/2026 sale and any later sale date, a ruling that no sale may run until her appeal is decided in writing, an order that the servicer issue that decision, and costs.
Exhibits attached: None.
The Timeline
2/14/2006. The borrower’s grant deed records, conveying Unit 934 and Unit 836 to her. A $1,000,000 deed of trust, dated 2/1/2006, records the same afternoon.
12/14/2017. An earlier Notice of Default on this deed of trust records, per county property records.
9/20/2023. A Notice of Rescission records, per county property records.
9/28/2023. A loan modification of the deed of trust records, per the recorded Notice of Default.
5/15/2024. A second Notice of Default records, per county property records.
12/6/2024. A Notice of Rescission of the second Notice of Default records, per county property records.
2/1/2025. The borrower stops making payments. The installment due on this date and the installments after it go unpaid, per the recorded Notice of Default.
10/28/2025. The foreclosure trustee records the current Notice of Default, showing $56,406.80 past due.
1/9/2026. The servicer tells the borrower her modification application is complete, per the complaint.
1/15/2026. The servicer denies a modification because the maximum number of modifications for the property has been reached, per the complaint.
2/16/2026. The borrower says she appealed that denial in writing.
3/26/2026. The trustee records the Notice of Trustee’s Sale. Sale set for 4/28/2026.
4/7/2026. The servicer tells the borrower her application is complete, per the complaint.
5/13/2026. The servicer again tells the borrower her application is complete, per the complaint.
7/2/2026. The servicer tells the borrower her latest application is complete, per the complaint.
7/6/2026. The servicer denies the application on the same ground and allows an appeal through 8/5/2026, per the complaint.
7/29/2026. The borrower says she submitted a written appeal.
8/5/2026. The servicer thanks the borrower for “additional documentation needed to process” her request, per the complaint.
8/6/2026. The servicer tells a regulator the review and appeal are “fully completed,” per the complaint.
8/18/2026. The servicer confirms in writing that the 8/18/2026 sale is postponed to 9/29/2026, per the complaint.
8/27/2026. The borrower says she sent the servicer a formal demand for a fresh review.
9/18/2026. The servicer acknowledges the demand and says it asked the investor about postponing the sale, per the complaint.
9/28/2026. The borrower files this lawsuit.
9/29/2026. The trustee’s sale goes ahead. The sale price is $1,660,500.00, per the trustee’s website.
The Money
$1,950,000. The borrower’s 2006 purchase price, per county property records. The transfer tax on the recorded grant deed matches it.
$1,000,000. The loan amount, per the recorded deed of trust. It is an interest-only adjustable-rate loan that matures March 1, 2036.
$56,406.80. Past due as of October 24, 2025, per the recorded Notice of Default.
$1,929,274.68. The unpaid balance plus estimated costs when the sale notice first published, per the recorded Notice of Trustee’s Sale.
$500 a month. New Social Security income the borrower says she reported to the servicer by phone.
$1,660,500.00. The sale price on September 29, 2026, per the trustee’s website.
Claim 1. Dual Tracking and the Modification Appeal (§ 2923.6)
The borrower says the servicer did not decide her July 29, 2026 appeal in writing. Her own complaint says the servicer reported on August 6 that the appeal was complete.
What the statute requires
Once a borrower submits a complete first-lien modification application at least five business days before a sale, the sale waits until, among other events, a written denial issues and the appeal period ends.
The borrower gets at least 30 days to appeal a denial. After a timely appeal, the sale waits at least until 15 days after the appeal is denied.
A written denial gives the reasons, including the specific reasons when the investor disallowed the modification.
The servicer does not have to evaluate a new application from a borrower already evaluated, unless a material change in finances is documented by the borrower and submitted to the servicer.
The application, appeal and waiting rules do not apply to servicers of seven or fewer California residential loans a year.
The section applies only to a first lien on owner-occupied residential property of up to four units.
What the borrower alleges
She pleads that the property is her principal residence, and points to the July 6 denial, which she says called it “the owners primary residence.” She says the servicer declared her application complete on July 2 and denied it July 6 because the investor’s limit on modifications had been reached. She says she appealed July 29 and has not received a written decision. She also says she started receiving about $500 a month in Social Security after the denial, and reported it by phone during the servicer’s intake on her last two reviews.
What the record shows
The recorded 2006 deed of trust carries a Second Home Rider, signed by the borrower, stating that she “shall occupy, and shall only use, the Property as Borrower’s second home.” The complaint lists a San Francisco post office box as the borrower’s address, and county tax records show a San Francisco mailing address for both units.
The recorded Notice of Default and Notice of Trustee’s Sale both recite a loan modification of this deed of trust recorded September 28, 2023. The declaration attached to the Notice of Default is signed for the servicer under § 2923.55, the borrower-contact section for larger servicers. The denial, the appeal and any income document are not attached.
Claim 2. Single Point of Contact (§ 2923.7)
The borrower says the servicer’s August 5 and August 6, 2026 statements contradicted each other. The complaint describes the second one as a response to a regulator, and attaches neither.
What the statute requires
When a borrower asks for a foreclosure prevention alternative, the servicer assigns a single point of contact, which can be a person or a team.
That contact explains the process and deadlines, coordinates documents and flags missing ones, gives current status, considers the alternatives the servicer offers, if any, and has access to someone who can stop the foreclosure.
The section does not apply to a servicer of seven or fewer California residential loans a year, and applies only to owner-occupied first liens.
What the borrower alleges
She says one letter thanked her for documents still being processed while the regulatory response said the review was over. She says the servicer did not identify a missing document, and the investor’s postponement decision was still pending eleven days before the sale.
What the record shows
No recorded document addresses the servicer’s staffing. The letters, the regulatory response and the September 18, 2026 acknowledgment are not attached.
Claim 3. Written Acknowledgment of Application Documents (§ 2924.10)
The borrower says the servicer took 22 days to acknowledge her August 27, 2026 demand for a fresh review. Her complaint says that demand did not state the $500 in new monthly income.
What the statute requires
When a borrower submits a complete first-lien modification application, or a document in connection with one, the servicer acknowledges receipt in writing within five business days.
The first acknowledgment describes the process and timing, deadlines, document expiration dates and any deficiency.
The section does not apply to servicers of seven or fewer California residential loans a year, and applies only to owner-occupied first liens.
What the borrower alleges
She says the servicer moved her file between complete, reopened, closed, processing and fully completed. She says the servicer answered her August 27 demand on September 18, more than five business days later, saying only that a response would come within the applicable period.
What the record shows
The August 27 demand is not attached. The complaint does not allege that a new application form or an income document went with it.
Claim 4. Accuracy of the Foreclosure Documents (§ 2924.17)
The borrower says the trustee’s listing names the wrong unit. The legal description in her own grant deed and deed of trust is Unit 934 and Unit 836, the same two units the recorded notices describe.
What the statute requires
A Notice of Default, Notice of Trustee’s Sale, assignment, substitution of trustee or contact declaration recorded by or for a servicer must be accurate, complete and supported by competent and reliable evidence.
Before recording, the servicer reviews that evidence to confirm the default and the right to foreclose.
What the borrower alleges
She says the trustee’s public listing describes the property as “400 Resort Road #834 and #934-L,” ZIP 96145. Her records and the servicer’s letters, she says, show Units 834 and 836, ZIP 96146. She says nobody gave her the recorded sale notice, so she cannot tell whether it carries the same error.
What the record shows
The grant deed and the deed of trust, both recorded February 14, 2006, describe “Unit 934, and 836.” The deed of trust gives the street address as “Unit 834 and Unit 836.” The recorded Notice of Default and Notice of Trustee’s Sale describe “Unit 934 and 836” and list both parcel numbers. Their street line reads “#834 and #934-L,” and the sale notice states that the trustee disclaims liability for any incorrect street address. The sale notice recorded March 26, 2026, six months before the complaint.
Claim 5. Declaratory and Injunctive Relief (§ 2924.12, § 2924b, § 2924f)
The borrower asked the court to stop the September 29, 2026 sale while she waited for an appeal decision and asked for proof of mailing, posting and publication. The sale ran the next day.
What the statute requires
Before a trustee’s deed records, a borrower can sue to enjoin a material violation of the listed sections, including §§ 2923.6, 2923.7, 2924.10 and 2924.17. After it records, the remedy is actual economic damages.
No violation affects a sale to a bona fide purchaser for value without notice.
The person who mails the notices by certified mail also sends a first-class copy, then signs and keeps an affidavit of mailing. Absent fraud, that affidavit conclusively establishes the mailing.
A wrong street address on the sale notice does not affect its validity when the notice also gives a legal description or parcel number.
What the borrower alleges
She says the sale notice did not reach her by certified mail. She says she asked for the mailing affidavit, proof of posting, publication and recording, and the trustee’s authority, and did not get them. She says she does not ask the court to find a violation from non-receipt alone.
What the record shows
The trustee’s website lists the sale on September 29, 2026 at $1,660,500.00. It does not say who bought the property. A property report dated October 25, 2026 does not list a trustee’s deed.
🔒 Paid below: the takeaway and three lessons for lenders.


