The sentence “and subject to the jurisdiction thereof,” is fuzzy st best and confusing, leading to disruptive contemporary political reinterpretations. Does it apply to the person born, or the parents, or the land on which the person is born?
What was the history of reasoning for this sentence in the amendment?
It is a murky phrase. This amendment was passed for the benefit of the slaves and no one else. It was to give slaves equal rights. This Amendment never contemplated what it turned into, it never contemplated that anyone giving birth on American soil automatically becomes its citizen. The case this interpretation is based on is a bad precedent. Let’s see what the Supreme Court does with it.
The sentence “and subject to the jurisdiction thereof,” is fuzzy st best and confusing, leading to disruptive contemporary political reinterpretations. Does it apply to the person born, or the parents, or the land on which the person is born?
What was the history of reasoning for this sentence in the amendment?
It is a murky phrase. This amendment was passed for the benefit of the slaves and no one else. It was to give slaves equal rights. This Amendment never contemplated what it turned into, it never contemplated that anyone giving birth on American soil automatically becomes its citizen. The case this interpretation is based on is a bad precedent. Let’s see what the Supreme Court does with it.